1.Tariffs: count for 1% of GDP for both the US and China, cumulatively.

In late March 2018, US President Donald Trump announced steel and aluminum tariffs of 25% and 10%, respectively, for Chinese imports to the US, as an effort to revitalize domestic industries and improve trade deficit with China, as of $375 billion. As a counteraction policy, the Chinese government responded with a $50 billion annual levy on imported US products mainly focusing on soybeans, pork, wine and US pipes. These actions from both sides were enough to generate an exchange of announcements with proposed tariffs up to 25% for 2500[i] products.

As can be seen from the charts below, in terms of the bilateral trade relationship, on an aggregate level, China exports 19% of its national gross trade volume to the US, making the latter China’s largest trading partner; while it imports around 7% of its trading volume from the US. For the US, Chinese tariffs amount to 0.3% of the US GDP, while cumulatively tariffs count for 1% of the GDP of both countries.

Consequently, although tariffs are estimated to have a negative effect on both economies, in the long run, the magnitude of the tariffs is expected to have a limited effect relative to the volume of trade for the world’s largest economies. As of today, in a scenario that there is no further escalation, the overall level of tariffs shouldn’t be considered a threatening activity for the global economy.

 

2.The Trade Dispute: Is China to Blame?

The US government had a tough stance on China, while the Chinese policy response was proportionate in terms of magnitude. From a macro perspective, Trump’s administration is focusing on China’s future by addressing high-tech industries, including robotics, aerospace, maritime, electric vehicles and modern rail equipment. These are also the industries that the Chinese government relies on to achieve its ambitious Belt and Road Initiative (BRI) – the largest infrastructure and investment project plan in history – that will enable China to achieve connectivity and cooperation between Eurasian countries and the rest of the world.

Although the popular view is that the US wanted to initiate a trade war with China, the reality is that the dispute has been triggered from China’s unfair trade methods. International concerns against China’s distorting trade practices have been expressed by the US, EU and Japan in the WTO. Especially in Europe, French President Emmanuelle Macron has been calling for stricter rules, more investigations and greater transparency on Chinese investments in the continent. To that extent, US tariffs on Chinese products signal the need for China to correct its distorting trade methods and comply with the international trade rules.

According to WTO rules (GATT 1994[ii]), dumping activities (selling a product to the importing country at a lower price than the price in the exporting country), as well as state sector subsidies and forced tech transfers (grants to support specific interest industries), are considered a violation of the international trading rules.

Assessing the US-China trade relationship, it is true that Chinese authorities have forced American companies to transfer intellectual properties to the  government in order to conduct business in China. As of today, the amount of intellectual property that is kept by the Chinese authorities is estimated to be valued at $300 billion.

China also imposes selected restrictions and tariffs on specific products to support domestic industries and spur export driven growth. There is a 25% tariff on imported US vehicles in China relative to some 2.5% federal duties in the US. By the same token, regarding the financial markets, China’s financial services have been characterized with a certain level of protectionism by foreign investors, modeled to protect the domestic economy – a closed capital account – and support the creation of global Chinese financial institutions.

However, the closeness of the financial sectors makes sense since China is still an emerging economy and opening fully its financial markets to international capital flows might increase economic vulnerability to systemic crisis. Nonetheless, the main point is that the overall investment environment regarding foreign investments is attractive (in terms of prices, costs, growth and returns), yet not welcoming, to foreign investors in China. Admittedly, China has to implement structural reforms aimed to improve its domestic market and the rule of law.

 

3.The Opportunity: Energy, Agriculture, Robotics.

The US-China trade differences are likely to be solved without further escalations. It is also highly plausible that China will not overreact in trade retaliation and will try to find a solution satisfying the American needs.

That said, it is suitable that the Chinese will come up with a specific plan including proposals to improve the trade imbalance of $375 billion.  That means that it is likely to import more from the US to maintain a good trade relationship.  A convincing, intelligent, mutually beneficial outcome in the negotiations may include sectors where the US is interested in expanding and China interested in developing further, such as energy, agriculture and robotics.

Purchasing liquified natural gas (LNG) from the US will add to Chinese energy diversification and reinforce US-energy dominance, while buying agricultural products will help China to curb its shortage and further improve the ambitious development of a global wine production in Changyu.  At the end, striving for a better deal in intellectual property rights for technology will support the creation and advancement of the robotics sectors in China. China’s initiative to upgrade its industry under the “Made in China 2025” program by applying information technology to boost production and achieve qualitative outcomes is aligned with the goal of cooperating strongly with the US as a major tech-trade partner. Interestingly, as a spin-off effect, tariffs may benefit other countries to increase their trade volumes in China. For instance, German robotics and manufacturing companies are likely to benefit, as well as Brazilian and Australian commodities and agricultural products.

 

4.Geopolitics: North Korea, Iran, Trans-Pacific Partnership.

From a geopolitical perspective, there is an additional pressure on China to comply with the American “trade requests”, discounting the upcoming meeting of US President Donald Trump with the Supreme Leader of North Korea Kim Jong Un, in late May or early June 2018. Factoring in any possible agreement towards the de-nuclearization of North Korea and the normalization of the US-North Korea relationships will be declared as a significant victory for the US. To that extent, China as a major trading partner of North Korea – oil supplier – has been criticized by the US for providing oil that can be used for the development of nuclear weapons, threatening the US security. Similarly, to this relationship, China has special interests in Iran, where the US President Donald Trump is likely to push for a new nuclear deal framework.

An additional geopolitical pressure for China is the willingness of the US President to re-negotiate the Trans-Pacific Partnership (TPP). The US is currently working on bilateral trade agreements with six of the eleven member-states. Any progress towards an effective implementation of the partnership may indirectly affect China. This can be done, with the US establishing trade relationships with the member-states of the TPP, by enforcing prohibition of transshipments from China, which plays a significant role in the Asia pacific region.  Put it differently, this means that the US is likely to ban products that include Chinese components (or have been transshipped from China) in the TPP negotiations.

 

5. Net Outcome: A deal that improves Trade Imbalances.

Under those circumstances, it is very likely that China will try to negotiate on fair terms and satisfy the US requests to improve trade imbalances.  For the global economy, the negotiations on tariffs must be engineered smartly and concisely in order to generate minimum losses, mitigate additional risks for both sides and maintain the overall positive, synchronized global momentum of growth.  Any trade policy confrontation dips the equity markets and increases policy uncertainty that is expressed with spiking volatility and shifting capital inflows towards safe assets and gold. All in all, the net outcome is that a deal is likely to be reached. Logic and reasoning must prevail in the trade US-China negotiations, since nobody favors a trade war, especially between the two biggest economies of the world.  For this reason, it is likely that the Chinese government would take an extra step to come closer to the US, while it will pursue its own interests. Going in that direction will help China to move faster and more stable in its economic cycle.

 

 

 

Ending Notes

[i] Up to 25% tariff on 1300 Chinese products entering the US market, and 1200 US products entering the Chinese market.

[ii]  WTO Rules – Article VI GATT 1994: https://www.wto.org/english/docs_e/legal_e/19-adp.pdf

Georgios Theocharis
Investment Strategist

Disclaimer:

This market commentary is merely for informational purposes. It should not be considered an investment proposal to buy, sell or hold securities, financial instruments or investment products.  It contains opinions and views of our analysts, at the date of issue.

← All Insights