More governments around the world seem to understand that social promises of pension plans they hold with their citizens might no longer be sustainable, and they have to be reformed. In the western world, low and negative interest rates, aging demographics, and longer life expectancy are among the key reasons that many institutions might not be able to meet their pension obligations in the future; and are likely to offer pensioners cuts in their retirement incomes.

With the baby boomer generation reaching their threshold age of retirement in 2022 to 2025, there is a case that pension funds will not be able to meet their promises to fund their clients’ pensions. This will certainly affect the current generation that is about to retire (baby boomers), and it will also have consequences to future retirees (both Generation X and Millennials) who have to work longer hours, and contribute more from their incomes, to pay for those who are about to retire, and then for themselves.

People entering retirement tend to have different economic behaviour compared to the next generations. For example, if they rely only on their pension, as the main source of income, retirees will likely decrease their consumption during their retirement period. As a result, on an aggregate level, having more people retired and out of the labour force will increase savings and reduce consumption, which push yields lower.

Among the same age group, another factor relates to portfolio allocation. US citizens tend to hold more stocks in their pension plans, while EU citizens have a higher exposure to bonds. People about to retire in the US have invested mainly in the stock market, through their pension contributions via their salaries – the 401K plan. A continuation of a strong stock market performance, with equities offering robust returns adjusted for inflation, is likely to generate adequate returns to curb pensions funding.

However, a “timely wrong” correction of the equity market is likely to wipe off part of retirees’ income. On the contrary, European citizens – of the same age group- have increased their fixed income allocation by holding core bonds to secure future cash flows during their retirement period. As a result, they have different portfolios relative to their peers in the US. With $15 trillion bonds currently trading with negative yields and other in suppressed yields near the zero-lower bound, pensions funding has triggered alarm bells.

There are concerns among regulators that pension funds might struggle to meet payment liabilities to their clients as a result of unconventional monetary measures and low-interest rates. To compensate for low interest rates, market participants have increased their positions towards illiquid assets, partially in search for higher yields.  In other words, they have taken more risk, in order to generate higher returns, by putting at stake liquidity that funds pensions.

From a monetary policy perspective, among others, secular changes in the economy, such as increased life expectancy, demographics, and low productivity, have rendered central banks powerless to raise long-term interest rates. Conversely, to avoid a future economic downturn, central banks will have to cut rates again, pushing yields lower than their current levels, by increasing the liabilities of a typical pension scheme.  In this scenario, the fixed income market will be vulnerable to a shock.

Mounting fears over lack of pensions funding must be taken seriously by regulators, as well as individual investors and future retirees. As an economic policy response, we are expecting an increase of the retirement age, changes in the retirement systems and/or further cuts in pension benefits. All of these are likely to come with certain political costs.

Moving ahead, it is likely that pension claims will be disruptive to equity markets, when the “baby boomer’s generation hits the threshold age of retirement in the coming years. We advise our clients to hold a certain percentage of cash positions, while diversifying their investments further targeting dividends by income generating strategies.

Georgios Theocharis
Investment Strategist

Disclaimer:

This market commentary is merely for informational purposes. It should not be considered an investment proposal to buy, sell or hold securities, financial instruments or investment products.  It contains opinions and views of our analysts, at the date of issue.

← All Insights