After the US election in November 2016, there has been a strong performance in the US stock market, with a remarkably positive change in the expectations of the agents (business sentiment) regarding the future of the US economy.

The question that arises is whether this performance is economically justified. Market participants have called it the “Trump Effect”, referring to the ability of the US President to manipulate the “animal spirits” in financial markets, followed by changes in certain regulations after his election, towards the development of a more business-friendly economic environment in the US.

With attention to the latter, an interesting developing trend can be seen in the behavior of the US-corporate sector (as a whole). Analyzing and monitoring this trend can give us – a proxy – for the future performance of the market.

Looking from a macro perspective, there has been a tremendous shift in the supply of savings to the global economy from households in the 1980 to corporations in 2010[i]. On an aggregate level, the private sector today is responsible for almost 2/3 of the world’s investments.  With the global economy recovering from a period of secular stagnation, corporations have strengthened their positions with mergers and/or acquisitions of other companies that lead to the creation of large conglomerations; responsible for trading billions of dollars, on a daily basis. As a result, more attention should be given on how the corporate sector behaves in the economy and how it responds to new policies, since private sector’s contribution is profoundly higher than households.

Under those circumstances, while some corporations (JP Morgan, Citi) have welcomed the US tax-cut with higher pay-checks for their employees and executive staff; and announcements for future expansion of their business services through capital investments (mainly in R&D, fin-tech, artificial intelligence, cybersecurity), others have used a portion of their tax-cut savings, as an opportunity to purchase back their own corporate shares.

Notably, since the pass of the US tax bill Dec.22 2017, there has been approximately $100 billion in stock buybacks in the US. Fundamentally, this reinforces the upward trend of equities, since it increases demand. For example, as of today, Wells Fargo has announced a buyback of $22.6 billion, Comcast $7 billion, GM $5 billion, adding up to previous year’s buyback purchases of Amgen’s 10 billion, Alphabet’s 8.6billion, Visa’s 7.5, McDonald’s $15 billion etc.

What is interesting in ending a period of unconventional monetary policies, is that stocks repurchasing has been a global phenomenon.  Similar trends, with the US stock market, have appeared in Europe and Japan. However, a startling difference is that the rate and the pace of stock repurchasing, is significantly higher in the US market than the rest of the world.  Of course, recent fiscal changes, including the tax cut and the repatriation of capital to the US economy (capital inflows) have accelerated the process and added to the buyback momentum.

Therefore, the pace of purchasing back stocks has contributed  to the upward trend of the stock market, since the stock market has performed profoundly well (doubled), while the earnings per share for the S&P index are only 6% higher than pre-crisis levels of 2008[ii] (using Prof. Schiller’s, CAPE ratio).

In the final analysis, we can expect a continuation of an upward trend in the US stock market mainly due to fiscal changes and the deregulation push by the new administration. Extra attention should be given to the corporate sector since corporate buybacks can provide higher dividends for the shareholders, but can also add to future volatility, in case it expresses itself. At least for the first half of 2018, is more likely to see corporations buying back their stocks and then increase their capital expenditures.

 

 

Ending Notes:

[i] “The global corporate saving glut: Long-term evidence”, Peter Chen, Loukas Karabarbounis, Brent Neiman, April 2017.
[ii]  CAPE, is an abbreviation for, cyclically adjusted price to earnings ratio. It is a valuation measure applied to the S&P 500 equity market. It is defined as price divided by the average of ten-year earnings, adjusted for inflation. The ratio is useful, since returns on earnings are volatile through years, so by incorporating a simple average in our valuations, we have a better indication about their long-term fundamental value of our investment on equities.

Georgios Theocharis
Investment Strategist

Disclaimer:

This market commentary is merely for informational purposes. It should not be considered an investment proposal to buy, sell or hold securities, financial instruments or investment products.  It contains opinions and views of our analysts, at the date of issue.

← All Insights