There is enough evidence that the implementation of unconventional monetary policies by major central banks has played a key role in easing conditions around the zero lower bound. Central banks that want to cut interest rates rely more on tool-kits of unconventional policies, such as large asset purchasing programs, changing inflation expectations, and negative interest rates.Negative interest rates are a way to get around the monetary effective lower bound that is defined as a point of switching into cash, which has a zero yield.
Santor and Suchanek (2013) argue about potential costs and vulnerabilities in the future from a prolonged period of unconventional measures. Their concerns are related to the unprecedented expansion of central banks’ balance sheets, credibility of the policies and the resilience of the financial system. The rationale behind the employment of negative interest rate policy is to deliver additional monetary stimulus and easier financial conditions, in order to support aggregate demand and price stability; within an environment of anemic growth and deflationary risks.
Under those conditions, cutting interest rates into a negative territory, lowers money market rates and flattens the yield curve. Specifically, flattering the yield curve can lead to substitution effects and portfolio rebalancing that can actually increase the effectiveness of monetary policy (Vinals 2016). In addition, Rohde (2015) suggested that the transmission mechanism of negative interest rates would be analogous to positive low interest rates, however there might be additional macro-prudential related risks, (Arteta et al 2016).
In favor of the employment of negative rates, Kocholerlakota (2016a) mentions that, it can be a better communications’ tool for central banks to re-affirm their commitment to price stability and reassess market expectations. Kocholerlakota argues that negative rates are likely to promote confidence in monetary policy and accelerate policy normalization. Nevertheless, there is evidence from recent empirical papers; focused on the implications of negative interest rates and their adverse effects on financing conditions (Waller 2016), and the links between interest rates and risk-taking activities. (Dell’Ariccia et al. 2013; Jimenez et al.2014)
To that extent, working papers from the International Monetary Fund (2016a, 2016b) have also expressed concerns about the liquidity of the financial markets associated with negative interest rates. As cited duration mismatches of investment spreads may pose threats of large money outflows of the financial institutions and firm-level closures if yields on bonds or other securities fall below the expected returns. Along similar lines, Bassman (2015) found that risk management models are associated with high volatility due to the element of risk-aversion implied by negative interest rates employed for a long period of time.
There is no compelling reason to argue that the duration of the policy is unimportant. Mac Andrews (2015) notes that prolonged periods of negative interest rates may encourage people to look for alternatives in order to either avoid or take advantage of the negative yield, that might result in a situation of holding cash “idle” rather than undertaking investments in the real economy.
Moreover, the implementation of the policy can also be seen as an opportunity to deleverage, since negative rates work inversely to debt service ratio, which improves debt sustainability and reduce market discipline by compressing sovereign bond yields, Hannoun (2015). That said, Jensen and Spanse (2015) by using the case of Denmark suggested that negative yields can give incentives for larger pre-payments of debt or taxes, in order for the borrower to gain a zero interest rate during the period.
Additionally, there is a rapidly growing research on the implications of the policy on the profitability of the banks. The basic argument relies on the reduction of the spread between lending and deposit rates. Spread reduction might force banks and other financial intermediaries to take excessive risk, to compensate for their losses. Although, current research seems to validate the view of an erosion of the profitability of the banks, Arteta et al (2016) argue that lending margins remain stable and within post-crisis ranges, credit growth has improved with the implementation of negative interest rates and financial spreads fall significantly on the announcement day of the policy by the central bank.
In the same way, Genay and Podjasek (2014) find that a low interest rate environment is associated with decreased profitability for banks, however they estimate the effect to be economically small and outweighed by other macroeconomic factors.Negative interest rates flatten the yield curve since it pushes down short and longer term rate, something that may be signaling economic uncertainty. There is sufficient evidence (Alessandri, Nelson 2012; Borio et al 2015) that both the level and the slope of the yield curve contribute to bank profitability in the long run.
Coeure (2014) argues that banks may borrow less from the central banks in a way to lower their excess reserves and avoid payments of negative rates, something that will diminish the simulative effect of negative interest rates. In the same way, Kupiec (2015) points that slowing down banking activities would decelerate market performance. He claims that there might a case that banks would prefer illiquid assets that would avoid liquid deposits if liquidity rules make it unprofitable to maintain bank deposit. Jobst and Lin (2016) mention that substantial cut rates may outweigh the benefits from higher assets values and stronger aggregate demand. Additionally, they argue that further accommodation can rely on credit easing; expansion of the balance sheet and the increase of inflation target (Blanchard, 2010).
To summarize, despite the ongoing the debate on the effectiveness of the policy, research on negative interest rates has been limited. The main reason relies on the lack of variations of policy rates by central banks and the short employment of the measure. An empirical investigation will require better data and with longer time series.
Georgios TheocharisInvestment Strategist
Disclaimer:
This market commentary is merely for informational purposes. It should not be considered an investment proposal to buy, sell or hold any security or investment product. It contains opinions and views of our analysts, at the date of issue.