Looking at the second half of 2019 and moving toward 2020, there are significant risks that can negatively affect financial markets. Among others, there are various risks associated with Hong Kong, where i) the abandonment of the peg mainly because of different market cycles between Hong Kong and the US; as well as ii) a potential credit crunch that is likely to be triggered from the real estate market and spread to Hong Kong’s banking system, are likely to pose concerns.
From a macro perspective, economic indicators might signal a future reversal of the current upward trend, big enough to formulate a boom – bust cycle. Although we believe that authorities in Hong Kong, have a proactive relative to reactive role in managing economic policy, weakening data have made us to examine a scenario of an economic slowdown in Hong Kong. Provided that Hong Kong is an important financial center, an economic slowdown is likely to affect neighboring countries in the region.
Historically, Hong Kong Dollar has been pegged to the US Dollar since 1983. The peg was introduced to stop a significant depreciation of the Hong Kong Dollar (HKD), which was sparked by the political negotiations over Hong Kong’s sovereignty between the UK and China. The two countries decided to peg Hong Kong’s currency to a third currency, the US dollar, as an economic arrangement to their political and administrative dispute. Today, under China’s constitutional principle of “One Country Two Systems”, Hong Kong has been transformed into a global financial center, and a trusted investment partner to China’s Economic Miracle.
Interestingly, as of today, the currency board is still run by the Hong Kong Monetary Authority (HKMA), which acts as the central bank of the country. However, economically speaking, HKMA does not engage in monetary policy because of the peg. In other words, HMKA has adopted FED’s monetary policy over the level of interest rates, inflation, and output. The decision to maintain the peg has proven beneficial, especially for the pegged currency (HKD) since over the years, both Hong Kong and the US have experienced synchronized economic growth.
However, in the presence of secular changes in the economy, that could disrupt this synchronicity, systemic risks are likely to appear. These risks are tied to the country experiencing a slowdown. For example, Hong Kong has benefited tremendously from the US financial crisis of 2008-09. The FED by cutting interest rates almost to zero levels as a response to the crisis, has helped Hong Kong – via the peg – to access lower cost of capital. Hong Kong seized the opportunity of low-interest rates and provided loans domestically and internationally. This has propelled economic growth both in Hong Kong as well as in China; which is Hong Kong’s largest trading partner.
Among others, Chinese firms have invested a part of their excess savings in Hong Kong’s real estate market, driving up the value of properties; while at the same time financial institutions in Hong Kong were increasing domestic credit by issuing loans to support this expansion. As a result, elevated levels of credit can explain high prices of real estate in Hong Kong.
Consequently, over that time period, low interest rates coupled with a credit expansion have created an overleveraged banking system in Hong Kong, estimated today as 900% of the country’s GDP. During the same time period, prices in real estate have increased 750%, making Hong Kong’s real estate market one of the most expensive in the world. Also, private sector’s credit has jumped to 300% of GDP. Global geopolitical events and market uncertainty over a potential escalation of a trade war between the US and China, raise additional concerns regarding the state of the economy and the ability of the HKMA to maintain the peg.
The reason is that HKMA has to buy US dollars when capital outflows push the exchange rate to the weaker trading band (to break the peg). HKMA can defend the peg, as long as, there are adequate reserves in the system. That said, HMKA officials claim that their resources are enough to successfully maintain the peg and spur further economic growth. In our base-case scenario, we believe that HMKA can defend peg, and raise additional capital along with other resources, if necessary. In our alternative scenario, there might be a revaluation of the current peg, which is likely to lead to a massive depreciation of HKD, a decline in the housing market, a spike in non-performing loans and an increase in the overall amount of debt. Lessons learned from previous financial crises have taught us that currency broads break unexpectedly, and deteriorations in the real estate market can ignite a credit crunch. In that case, the magnitude of the event is likely to be more significant when there is excessive leverage in the economy.
Georgios TheocharisInvestment Strategist
Disclaimer:
This market commentary is merely for informational purposes. It should not be considered an investment proposal to buy, sell or hold securities, financial instruments or investment products. It contains opinions and views of our analysts, at the date of issue.